Ulasan

Ulasan pengguna

LibraryThing Review

Komen Pengguna  - ssperson - LibraryThing

Yes, I finished this (the third book in the series) after I finished the fourth book. I left my copy of this book on a plane, and had to order another copy. However, I had the fourth book with me on ... Baca ulasan penuh

LibraryThing Review

Komen Pengguna  - EmScape - LibraryThing

Lowry ties together the stories in The Giver and Gathering Blue, giving us more insight into this world she has created and teaching the reader more important lessons. Baca ulasan penuh

LibraryThing Review

Komen Pengguna  - japaul22 - LibraryThing

The third book in Lowry's Giver quartet continues the story from Gathering Blue and starts to add in elements from The Giver. As in all of these books, Lowry leaves a lot to the individual reader's ... Baca ulasan penuh

LibraryThing Review

Komen Pengguna  - Welfycat - LibraryThing

I enjoyed this sequel to both of the first stories in the quartet, particularly that the story focused on Matty. The theme of human evolution both reoccurs and evolves in this book, with the addendum ... Baca ulasan penuh

LibraryThing Review

Komen Pengguna  - juniperSun - LibraryThing

It's been so long since I read Gathering Blue that I'm coming to this book with a tabula rasa. I really enjoyed the interactions of Matty and Seer, and could identify with his level of comfort and ... Baca ulasan penuh

LibraryThing Review

Komen Pengguna  - obtusata - LibraryThing

This one has a sad ending that doesn't completely resolve questions, but the story is still interesting and I'm looking forward to the next book. Baca ulasan penuh

LibraryThing Review

Komen Pengguna  - Faith_Murri - LibraryThing

While the plot issues with Gathering Blue weren't resolved in this one, it stood on it's own better as a story. I loved Matty in this, and all the other characters too, like Seer, Leader (who's ... Baca ulasan penuh

LibraryThing Review

Komen Pengguna  - cindywho - LibraryThing

I liked that she pulled together the characters from the previous books, but she also left too much unexplained about the gifts and the bad things that were happening to the people of village along with a preachy storyline about materialism and immigration. Baca ulasan penuh

LibraryThing Review

Komen Pengguna  - carlahaunted - LibraryThing

This addition to the Giver series felt more heavy-handed and preachy than the other two; I felt uncomfortable rather than intrigued or entranced while reading it. Baca ulasan penuh

LibraryThing Review

Komen Pengguna  - vickimarie2002 - LibraryThing

I love this series so much! There is so much to think about. I've been reading these with my son. Baca ulasan penuh

Penarafan pengguna

5 bintang
22
4 bintang
58
3 bintang
21
2 bintang
9
1 bintang
3

Semua ulasan - 122

Semua ulasan - 122
Ulasan editorial - 0

Semua ulasan - 122
Kirkus - 1